Product: Today’s we are reviewing Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover. Is this product as effective as the more expensive brands?
Overall Rating = 
4 Stars – Excellent
Cost: $5.82 for 5.5 oz. ($1.06 per fluid ounce) Price Category: Inexpensive
Sold By: Wal-mart; Walgreen’s; Retailers everywhere
Container: Plastic bottle with screw-off cap
Description: This is a clear liquid remover for all forms of eye makeup. According to the manufacturer it is, “effective and gentle”, “removes even waterproof mascara” with “no oily residue”. It also claims to be “Dermatologist Developed”. This is a fragrance-free product.
I was first introduced to Neutrogena products as a teenager, so needless to say I’ve had a lot of experience with this brand. (I haven’t been a teenager for a long time.) The Neutrogena brand began in 1930 in Switzerland, came to the USA in the 1950’s and was acquired by Johnson & Johnson in 1994 when it became a worldwide brand.
I’m going to be putting some Neutrogena products through some comparison tests to see if they can perform as well as products costing many times more.
Everyone who wears eye makeup needs a good remover that doesn’t burn, sting, and leave an oily film on their eyes or skin. The Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover, just like the Lancôme Bi-Facil, is a dual-phase product. It contains a lipid layer (slippery-feeling cleansing layer) and a water layer. The product must be shaken well prior to use to combine the two layers. If you insert a cotton swap into the bottle without shaking first you will just get the oily-feeling lipid layer. When the product is left standing still you can see the lipid layer rise to the top just as you will with an oil-and-vinegar salad dressing. When shaken, the product changes from two clear liquid layers to one milky-colored liquid.
Morning Review: I like to use this product with a sterile fresh cotton swab each time. To keep your product sterile, don’t put your fingers on top of the bottle and keep it tightly capped when not in use. A little goes a long way. This remover does have a very slight oily feel to it, but the consistency is closer to water than oil. There is almost no scent. The primary ingredient that I smell is aloe vera. This remover effectively removes all eye makeup, including waterproof mascara and gel eyeliner. It does not burn or sting my eyes or make them water. The remover is quickly absorbed into the skin and does not leave an oily residue. It leaves the skin around my eyes feeling smooth. I always rinse off any eye makeup remover prior to the application of skin-care and makeup products and I recommend you do the same.
Morning Rating = 4 Stars
Evening Review: I decided to really put this remover to a test. In the morning I put on a heavy eye makeup complete with concealer, primer, multiple eye shadows, gel eyeliner, liquid eyeliner and waterproof mascara. Several hours later I then removed the makeup from one eye with Lancôme Bi-Facil and the makeup from the other eye with the Neutrogena remover. They both performed exactly the same. It took the same amount of product to remove the makeup, which was two double-ended cotton swabs for each eye. (If you have a problem with cotton fibers getting into your eyes, you can use disposable foam applicators instead of cotton swabs or you can put a little remover onto a makeup wipe.) I did not have to tug or scrub to remove the makeup. They both worked effectively at removing all traces of eye makeup including stubborn and difficult-to-remove products. My makeup wipes did not find any traces of eye makeup. The skin around my eyes did not feel tight or irritated, and in fact, it felt soft and hydrated.
The primary difference was that my nose was running due to the fragrance in the Lancôme Bi-Facil and that does not happen when I just use the Neutrogena remover. Also, the Neutrogena absorbed into my skin faster than the Lancôme Bi-Facil did. Since I rinse it off anyway, this is not much of a factor, but there was slightly less oily residue with the Neutrogena.
Overall Review: Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover is an excellent eye makeup remover for all skin types and is gentle enough for those with contact lenses. This is a good product to use if you have fragrance allergies. This remover is suitable for both women and men. It is very affordable and readily available at most retailers.
If you see negative reviews for this product and complaints that it is too oily, I suspect that is due to the fact that the users did not shake it prior to application. The layers must be combined for the product to work effectively.
This remover is suitable for the following skin types:
- All ethnicities;
- All ages;
- All sexes;
- Dry;
- Sensitive;
- Consistent;
- Oily;
- Combination.
RATINGS REPORT:
Morning Rating = 4 Stars;
Evening Rating = 4 Stars;
Average from Other Testers = 4 Stars;
Value Rating = 4 Stars;
Overall Rating = 4 Stars – Excellent. (Please review the About 365 Cosmetic Reviews page for the rating info.)
Ingredients: Water, Cyclopentasiloxane, Cyclohexasiloxane, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice (Aloe Vera), Benzyl Alcohol, Sodium Chloride, Dipropylene Glycol, Poloxamer 182, Allantoin (Comfrey Root), Tripotassium EDTA, Benzalkonium Chloride Solution, Glycerin, Cucumber (Cucumis Sativus) Fruit Extract, Potassium Phosphate, Dipotassium Phosphate.
Important: Please read our full Disclaimer before using this or any product.
3 Stars – Good.
